What do you think?

[Red Leader]

Does anyone think I should trade 2B Marcus Giles and SS Nomar Garciaparra for 2B Chase Utley?

I have Garciaparra in one of my DL spots and he is to be activated tonight. I have 1 week to activate him, release him, or trade him. I have Michael Young at SS, so I don't really need Nomar.
The only position I can find on my team that needs upgrading is at 2B. Marcus just simply isn't providing the power or SB's I need, or expected. Utley is killing the ball, and steals bases.

Thoughts?

[ghettochild]

nomah hits well in august and sept, but this will be like may and june for him. he's also what 3-13 in his rehab? you're taking a chance with him IMO i think the cubs rushed him back too fast.

i could be wrong though, but i'd take it

[kheidg-]

I think I'd pass