PDA

View Full Version : My guess at the AS game!



Mario-Rijo
06-29-2006, 10:56 PM
My take on the NL AS Roster before voting is completed. This is a list of what I think will happen and not what I would necc. like to see happen. If AstroBuddy is around maybe he has some in depth ideas of what Phil Garner might lean towards as far as A,B or C players. Although I must admit I can't recall how many is allowed on the roster, something tells me 33 or 34. If someone can remember let me know. I am going w/ 34!


Fan Voting:
C- LoDuca- NYM
1B- Pujols- St. L
2B- Utley- Phil.
SS- Reyes- NYM
3B- Wright- NYM
LF- Bay- Pitt
CF- Griffey- Cincy
RF- Beltran- NYM

Pitchers:
Tom Glavine- NYM (Although another Met how can you keep him out?)
Brandon Webb- Arz
Brad Penny- LA
Jason Schmidt- S.F.
Carlos Zambrano- Chi
Trevor Hoffman- S.D.
Roy Oswalt- Hou
Bronson Arroyo- Cincy
Billy Wagner- NYM
Chris Carpenter- St. L
Jason Isringhausen- St. L
Tom Gordon- Phil
Aaron Harang- Cincy

Reserves:
Matt Holliday- OF- Col
Andruw Jones- OF- Atl.
Alfonso Soriano- OF- Was.
Lance Berkman- 1B- Hou.
Carlos Lee- OF- Mil
Miguel Cabrera- 3B/OF- Fla
Craig Biggio- 2B- Hou
David Eckstein- SS- St. L
Mike Piazza- C- S.D.
Jose Castillo- 3B- Pitt.
Ryan Howard- 1B- Phil
Nomar Garciaparra- 1B L.A.
Dan Uggla- 2B- Fla.


There's my list if in fact you can have 34. If not then Subtract Uggla and then if necc. Nomar I only added them because of how good their season has been! Man this was more difficult than I 1st thought, with all the teams included etc.,what do ya think?

HotCorner
06-29-2006, 11:03 PM
I would swap the following:

Castillo, PIT for Sanchez, PIT
Garciaparra, LA for Phillips, CIN
Piazza, SD for Estrada, ARI

Mario-Rijo
06-29-2006, 11:10 PM
I would swap the following:

Castillo, PIT for Sanchez, PIT
Garciaparra, LA for Phillips, CIN
Piazza, SD for Estrada, ARI

Yeah I thought about Estrada and if it were my decision I think I might, as a matter of fact I think perhaps you are right Garner probably would take Estrada. I took Piazza because of his popularity thinking maybe Garner would take that into consideration. Castillo though is hitting .363 and Nomar right behind him @ .362. Besides Sanchez & Phillips both play 2nd. If it were me it would be BP no question over everyone @ 2B including Utley but it's not.