PDA

View Full Version : The Reds prospect Team



jamess697
09-05-2006, 08:20 AM
C Miguel Perez AA
1B Joey Votto AA
2B Justin Turner R
SS Chris Valakia R
3B Aaron Herr AA
LF Javon Moran AA
CF Drew Stubbs R
RF Jay Bruce A

SP Homer Bailey AA
SP Travis Wood A
SP Johnny Cueto A
SP Jordan Smith R
SP Carlos Fisher A

RP Calvin Medlock AA
RP Sean Watson R
RP Jon Coutlangus AAA
RP Abe Woody A
RP Tyler Pelland AA
RP Travis Webb R


This is allright, I like our position prospects, and we have some real pitching prospects as far as I can see. The outlook in our future is bright. Hopefully Wayne does some good utilizing our prospects and we don't trade them all away.

cjtenn28
09-05-2006, 07:26 PM
Cody Strait and Paul Janish should make this team. How far have Mark Schmarek and B.J. Symenski (sp) have fallen. I still hold out hope for both.

As for the pitching.

Sam Leclure, James Avery, Phil Dumatrait should get some love.

Superdude
09-05-2006, 08:01 PM
C) ? (Perez if you forced me to pick one)
1B) Votto
2B) Brendan Harris
SS) Janish
3B) Aaron Herr
OF) Bruce
OF) Stubbs
OF) Dickerson/Strait

SP) Bailey
SP) Cueto
SP) Wood
SP) Vasquez
SP) Lecure

RP) Medlock
RP) Pelland
RP) Guevara
RP) Fisher
RP) Shafer
RP) Watson (if he takes that route)


How exactly do you see Travis Webb and Jordan Smith on the team?

jesusfan
09-05-2006, 08:02 PM
Janish over Valaika?

mth123
09-05-2006, 08:33 PM
Aaron Herr as the choice at 3B makes me thankful that Edwin is young. I guess I put Milton Loo there. I like Valaika over Janisch. Superdude seems to have the right 5 starters. We should just play w/o a catcher.

Wouldn't mind more discussion of the relievers. Don't know much about the upside of these guys. Got some info on Pelland in another thread and thought Coutlangus was pretty good.

Patrick Bateman
09-05-2006, 09:24 PM
Cody Strait and Paul Janish should make this team. How far have Mark Schmarek and B.J. Symenski (sp) have fallen. I still hold out hope for both.




Schmarek is basically done. He's never hit, and considering he was "the most polished hitter in the draft" according to Jimbo, that's pretty bad.

Syzmanski has a better chance, but that's not saying much.

OnBaseMachine
09-05-2006, 09:52 PM
1B Joey Votto
2B Brendan Harris
SS Chris Valaika
3B Milton Loo
OF Chris Dickerson
CF Drew Stubbs
OF Jay Bruce
C Miguel Perez (by default)

RHP Homer Bailey
RHP Johnny Cueto
LHP Travis Wood
RHP Sam Lecure
LHP Jamie Arneson

I gave Arneson the nod over Carlos Fisher due to age. I know Arneson is only at Billings, however: he's a 6'5 lefty with a fastball in the low 90's and has strong periphals.

RHP Calvin Medlock
RHP David Shafer
RHP Brad Salmon
LHP Jon Coutlangus
RHP Carlos Guevara
RHP Derrik Lutz
RHP Sean Watson
LHP Tyler Pelland

Betterread
09-05-2006, 10:06 PM
C - Miguel Perez
1B - Joey Votto
2B - Brendan Harris
SS - Chris Valaika
3B - Milton Loo
OF - Jay Bruce
OF - Drew Stubbs
OF - Chris Denorfia (he's has not played 50 games yet for the Reds -but when he does I will replace him with Danny Dorn)

SP - Homer Bailey
SP - Travis Wood
SP - Johnny Cueto
SP - Tyler Pelland (I still hold out hope he can command a curveball and become a ML starter)
SP - Sam LeCure

RP - Sean Watson
RP - Rafael Gonzalez
RP - Jamie Arneson
RP - Derrick Lutz
RP - David Shafer (Terrell Young just misses the cut - he has tremendous stuff if he ever learns to control it - he will sail through the system quickly 22 IP, 11hits, 29 Ks and 19 at Billings )

Aronchis
09-05-2006, 10:26 PM
C: Perez
1st: Votto(will start at some point with the Reds)
2nd: Harris
SS: Valakia
3rd: Loo(Breakout prospect for 2007)
OF: Bruce(My choice for biggest improvement)
OF: Stubbs(Prey)
OF: Strait(could surprise)

SP: Bailey(development may slow down a little next year)
SP: Wood(could fly the highest next year)
SP: Cueto
SP: Lecure(my choice for biggest improvement on his overall numbers next year)
SP: Pelland(command a second pitch my man, success will be yours in some role)

RP:Young(my break out pitcher for 2007)
RP:Shafer
RP:Gonzo(one last shot next year, the tools are there, but is the mind?)
RP:Medlock
RP:Guevara
RP:Woody