Most Scrappy Wins.

[Raisor]

Mid August poll time!

Which Red is most scrappy?!

And why?

[Raisor]

I'm going with Votto. First base isn't usually where you'll find the most scrappy player, but Joey is Canadian and is probably missing a few teeth from the hockey, and that's scrappier then american players going to the Gap and stuff.

[RedsManRick]

It should be a scrap to the death between Rosales and Taveras. Votto is too smooth to be scrappy.

[guttle11]

Rosales doesn't actually exist, he's just a hologram collage of images left over from Ryan Freel, Brady Clark, Chris Stynes, and THE Chris Denorfia.

[Raisor]

It should be a scrap to the death between Rosales and Taveras. Votto is too smooth to be scrappy.

Votto only seems "smooth" since he's an exotic international player.

[corkedbat]

I voted for Taveras. I read it wrong and thought it said, "Most Crappy"

[Highlifeman21]

Janish, b/c he's pitched 2.0 IP this season.

[nate]

It's absolutely Adam Rosales. He even made it into a commercial for FSN.

[15fan]

http://static.howstuffworks.com/gif/how-scooby-doo-works-3.jpg

Herrera gets my vote.

He's the one on the far left.

When you're shorter than the ball boys, you can't be anything other than scrappy.

[TheNext44]

Hanigan does the most with the least "skills". Hard nosed and scrappy.

Herrera is a close second. I'm about his height, so if I make him the most scrappy, I'm admitting that shortness is a handicap, which I will never do.

I only count players who actually do something with their scrappyness, so Taveras and Rosales don't count. Rosales might count next year if he is used in the right role.

[Chip R]

I think you have a lot of time on your hands, Raisor.

[BoydsOfSummer]

I'm going with the sort of scrappy we aren't used to. Danny ray Herrera--scrappy and effective!

[KronoRed]

This team certainly is loaded down with scrap

[*BaseClogger*]

I vote Alex Gonzalez. It's clear he isn't healthy, yet he's still out there grinding back from injuries. Also, he has 6 sac bunts and 2 HBPs...

[marcshoe]

I voted Phillips, because he has ran into the most outs. I do realize he loses points for actually being good, however.

[Ron Madden]

This team certainly is loaded down with scrap


I'll second that motion.

[reds44]

Rosales is the definition of scrap.

[Edskin]

In order to be scrappy, you must be...

--white
--somewhat young
--not very talented
--always run hard

Rosales fits the bill to a tee

[Roy Tucker]

I voted for Herrera just because he reminds me of that punk kid that always showed up at the gym for a pickup game and annoyed the heck out of everyone.

This team has a lot of scrap.

[wolfboy]

Herrera. He's shorter than my grandma and grandma can throw harder.

< grandma = maximum scrappy

[Eric_the_Red]

Reds '09: A great big festering pile of scrap.