Re: Review: 'The Village' Shyamalan's best film yet
And here's the other perspective. Note, this guy gave four stars to "Signs."
http://www.suntimes.com/output/ebert...illage30f.html
THE VILLAGE / * (PG-13)
July 30, 2004
Lucius Hunt: Joaquin Phoenix
Ivy Walker: Bryce Dallas Howard
Edward Walker: William Hurt
Alice Hunt: Sigourney Weaver
Noah Percy: Adrien Brody
Kitty Walker: Judy Greer
Victor: Frank Collison
Jamison: Jesse Eisenberg
Touchstone Pictures presents a film written and directed by M. Night Shyamalan. Running time: 120 minutes. Rated PG-13 (for a scene of violence and frightening situations).
BY ROGER EBERT
"The Village" is a colossal miscalculation, a movie based on a premise that cannot support it, a premise so transparent it would be laughable were the movie not so deadly solemn. It's a flimsy excuse for a plot, with characters who move below the one-dimensional and enter Flatland. M. Night Shyamalan, the writer-director, has been successful in evoking horror from minimalist stories, as in "Signs," which if you think about it rationally is absurd -- but you get too involved to think rationally. He is a director of considerable skill who evokes stories out of moods, but this time, alas, he took the day off.
Critics were enjoined after the screening to avoid revealing the plot secrets. That is not because we would spoil the movie for you. It's because if you knew them, you wouldn't want to go. The whole enterprise is a shaggy dog story, and in a way, it is all secrets. I can hardly discuss it at all without being maddingly vague.
Let us say that it takes place in an unspecified time and place, surrounded by a forest the characters never enter. The clothing of the characters and the absence of cars and telephones and suchlike suggest either the 1890s, or an Amish community. Everyone speaks as if they had studied "Friendly Persuasion." The chief civic virtues are probity and circumspection. Here is a village that desperately needs an East Village.
The story opens with a funeral attended by all the villagers, followed by a big outdoor meal at long tables groaning with corn on the cob and all the other fixin's. Everyone in the village does everything together, apparently, although it is never very clear what most of their jobs are. Some farming and baking goes on.
The movie is so somber, it's afraid to raise its voice in its own presence. That makes it dreary even during scenes of shameless melodrama. We meet the patriarch Edward Walker (William Hurt), who is so judicious in all things he sounds like a minister addressing the Rotary Club. His daughter Ivy (Bryce Dallas Howard), is blind but spunky. The stalwart young man, Lucius Hunt (Joaquin Phoenix), petitions the elders to let him take a look into the forest. His widowed mother Alice (Sigourney Weaver), has feelings for Edward Walker. The village idiot (Adrien Brody), gambols about, and gamboling is not a word that I use lightly. There is a good and true man (Brendan Gleeson). And a bridegroom who is afraid his shirt will get wrinkled.
Surrounding the village is the forest. In the forest live vile, hostile creatures who dress in red and have claws of twigs. They are known as Those We Do Not Speak Of (except when we want to end a designation with a preposition). We see Those We Do Not Speak, etc., only in brief glimpses, like the water-fixated aliens in "Signs." They look better than the "Signs" aliens, who looked like large extras in long underwear, while Those We Do Not, etc., look like their costumes were designed at summer camp.
Watchtowers guard the periphery of the village, and flares burn through the night. But not to fear: Those We Do, etc., have arrived at a truce. They stay in the forest and the villagers stay in the village. Lucius wants to go into the forest and petitions the elders, who frown at this desire. Ivy would like to marry Lucius, and tells him so, but he is so reflective and funereal, it will take him another movie to get worked up enough to deal with her. Still, they love each other. The village idiot also has a thing for Ivy, and sometimes they gambol together.
Something terrible happens to somebody. I dare not reveal what, and to which, and by whom. Edward Walker decides reluctantly to send someone to "the towns" to bring back medicine for whoever was injured. And off goes his daughter Ivy, a blind girl walking through the forest inhabited by Those Who, etc. She wears her yellow riding hood, and it takes us a superhuman effort to keep from thinking about Grandmother's House.
Solemn violin dirges permeate the sound track. It is autumn, overcast and chilly. Girls find a red flower and bury it. Everyone speaks in the passive voice. The vitality has been drained from the characters; these are the Stepford Pilgrims. The elders have meetings from which the young are excluded. Someone finds something under the floorboards. Wouldn't you just know it would be there, exactly where it was needed, in order for someone to do something he couldn't do without it.
Eventually the secret of Those, etc., is revealed. To call it an anticlimax would be an insult not only to climaxes but to prefixes. It's a crummy secret, about one step up the ladder of narrative originality from It Was All a Dream. It's so witless, in fact, that when we do discover the secret, we want to rewind the film so we don't know the secret anymore.
And then keep on rewinding, and rewinding, until we're back at the beginning, and can get up from our seats and walk backward out of the theater and go down the up escalator and watch the money spring from the cash register into our pockets.
Copyright © Chicago Sun-Times Inc.
Re: Review: 'The Village' Shyamalan's best film yet
Quote:
Originally Posted by TeamCasey
(Thought I'd start a new threat. I think a few folks will get out to see this one.)
http://trizomi21.artistique-ilustra..../cornholio.jpg
Re: Review: 'The Village' Shyamalan's best film yet
Wow! :eek: It's too bad Roger Ebert didn't tell us how he really felt. I tend to agree with him more often than not though. I am interested in seeing Ron Howard's daughter.
Re: Review: 'The Village' Shyamalan's best film yet
The Enquirer didn't have much good to say about it either.
http://www.cincinnati.com/freetime/m...hevillage.html
Skip the trip
to 'The Village'
By Margaret A. McGurk
The Cincinnati Enquirer
The Village
Score: 2 (out of 10)
Rating:
(PG-13 A scene of violence, frightening situations)
Cast:
Joaquin Phoenix, Bryce Dallas Howard.
Director:
Directed by M. Night Shyamalan.
Time:
118 minutes.
Don't go into the woods. No, really. Don't bother.
If you do venture into the forested thickets of The Village, you risk getting bogged down in a silly stunt of a movie from a guy who should know better.
Fright-maven M. Night Shyamalan (The Sixth Sense, Signs) shoves his talented cast into contrivances so tortured they squeal, in service of a plot that amounts to little more than a prank. Not to mention the fact that despite elaborate publicity stunts and stern warnings to avoid giving away the movie's "secrets," very little happens on screen that can't be predicted by any reasonably attentive viewer.
The setting is what looks like some kind of 19th-century cult outpost where everyone speaks in the starchy patois of a Colonial Williamsburg tour guide. The village is surrounded by thick woods guarded by torch lights and yellow banners meant to keep away unseen creatures who are so scary that sentries spend the night in towers to warn of any incursions. (How the villagers got into the village valley in the first place is never explained.)
The fearsome critters, we're told, have some kind of unspoken detente with the villagers: Leave us alone, and we'll do the same. Yet there are always young folks eager to tempt fate.
For the movie's purposes, it is Lucius Hunt (Joaquin Phoenix), a moody, tightly wound young man who wants to cross the woods to "the towns," which, though wicked, contain medicines that might prevent children from dying. Passing comments reveal that all the village elders (including Sigourney Weaver and William Hurt) lost loved ones to violent crime in "the towns," and apparently fear bandits more than lethal diseases, so they discourage Lucius.
The other key character is Ivy Walker (Bryce Dallas Howard), a blind girl with preternatural navigational abilities who falls in love with Lucius and marries him just as the creatures seem to be on a rampage - skinning livestock, painting red slashes on buildings, stomping around town, growling, what have you.
Shyamalan throws in a tragedy involving a simpleton (Adrien Brody), then sends Ivy off to "the towns" on her own.
The Big Twist near the end is such a bore it's not worth revealing. Suffice it to say it's less than a shattering shock, and The Village is less than even middling quality entertainment.
E-mail mmcgurk@enquirer.com
Re: Review: 'The Village' Shyamalan's best film yet
I read one mediocre review and one great review.
I find that the best review is the one you make yourself. :lol:
Re: Review: 'The Village' Shyamalan's best film yet
Quote:
Originally Posted by GAC
I read one mediocre review and one great review.
I find that the best review is the one you make yourself. :lol:
Actually it was one great one and two bad ones. But, you're right. The best review is your own.
Re: Reviews: 'The Village'
Debating whether to see this or the Manchurian Candidate
Re: Reviews: 'The Village'
The Manchurian Candidate looks awesome! Easy choice! You can't go wrong with Denzel!
Re: Reviews: 'The Village'
Quote:
Originally Posted by savafan
Debating whether to see this or the Manchurian Candidate
The review that I read this morning that it is one of the best political thrillers to come around in awhile. Very intense.
Re: Reviews: 'The Village'
I just watched the original of "The Manchurian Candidate" a few weeks ago. Really liked it, but I'll probably wait for video to see the new one.
Regardless of reviews, I'll still see "The Village."
Re: Reviews: 'The Village'
I think SHAMalan is the most over-hyped director of the new milennium.
"I know, I know! We can get kids to whisper creepy things! People will eat it up. We'll make millions on everything we release after that!"
I think I'm finally gonna get around to seeing Coffee and Cigarettes instead.
Re: Reviews: 'The Village'
I have to say that except for Signs, I'm not a biggest Shyamalan fan ..... and I LOVE creepy things that go bump in the night. I also like movies that make you think a bit. I believe he tries to do both, but he really doesn't know what he wants to be.
Re: Reviews: 'The Village'
Just got home from seeing it. It was "ok". Ron Howard's daughter was the best thing about the film, she was very good.
Re: Reviews: 'The Village'
Ahh, a review from a layman. Thanks Raisor. Always like to hear the non-critics' opinions.