I'm not overly familiar with his playing, but it seems like the reports about him don't value him super highly (especially considering where he went in the draft).
RedsZone farm experts, what do you think?
Printable View
I'm not overly familiar with his playing, but it seems like the reports about him don't value him super highly (especially considering where he went in the draft).
RedsZone farm experts, what do you think?
He has a very high ceiling, but his chances are poor. To me he's a "boom or bust" prospect. If everything clicks he could be a special player, but considering his skills are very unrefined for his age, the odds are that he will be a bust.
I would give him at least 2 to 3 more years to work out his problems. To label any of our farm system players a bust after just 1 year of rookie ball is unfair. What if Bruce bats .220 next year do we label him a bust. Minor league players need time this isnt pro football.
I doubt it. Supposedly, he plays premium defense in CF already, major league quality (I have no idea if this is true). Even if he struggles with the bat for a couple years, he'll still be seen as a player with a high ceiling, meaning he'll have value in a trade package. He'd have to get really bad at the plate with an accompanying erosion in his play defensively and on the basepaths before he "busts" completely.
LIncoln Curtis
John Oliver
Chad Mottola
Pat Watkins
Don Watannabe
get the arithmetic progression here
Pat Watkins is an ideal comp for Stubbs...
or perhaps St. Louis phenom Stubby Clapp.
Can you say, David Espinoza
No team can have too many prospects who are unable to hit the ball out of the infield.
I say make him part of a big trade before we find out.
He has a LONG way to go with his bat. His numbers scream out BJ Szymanski JR, and that is not a good thing.
Mike Frank?
Quote:
Was BJ a college All-American?
No. He was a latecomer as a prospect. He didn't really hit the radar till his junior year at Princeton, when he hit a long home run off Justin Verlander. He had nowhere near the scrutiny Stubbs did, who has been highly regarded since high school.
He was widely considered the best "athlete" in the draft because of his size, speed, defense and arm, similar to Stubbs. The question on both is exactly the same, will he hit? In the case of BJ it looks like he won't be able to do it and with all the question marks Stubbs sure didn't get off to a good start.