If you were GM what would you do in the next 10 days??
Here is what I do......
I attempt to play the teams that lose out on Halladay against each other and get the most value that I can for Harang. Right now the best deal that I have seen proposed has been the Yankees deal; Aaron Harang and Chris Dickerson/Drew Stubbs to New York for Phillip Hughes, Miguel Cabrera, and Jesus Montero.
I then look to deal one of the relievers of Weathers or Rhodes. I would attempt to package them with Arroyo and look at either the Dodgers or the Angels. I would still look at getting SS Brandon Wood from the Angels; Bronson Arroyo and David Weathers to the Angels for Brandon Wood and Sean O'Sullivan.
I also consider kicking the tires on a Francisco Cordero deal only because Hughes was obtained from the Yankees. It appears as though he has settled in nicely as a setup guy, according to Yankees' fans. Not sure what kind of return Cordero could get but I would think that he has some trade value right now.
This leaves the team after the trades like this.
C - Ryan Hanigan
1B - Joey Votto
2B - Brandon Phillips
SS - Brandon Wood
3B - Edwin Encarnacion
LF - Melky Cabrera
CF - Willy Taveras/Chris Dickerson
RF - Laynce Nix/Jonny Gomes/Jay Bruce when he is back from the DL
SP - Edinson Volquez
SP - Johnny Cueto
SP - Homer Bailey
SP - Micah Owings
SP - Matt Maloney/Travis Wood
Bullpen then consists of Masset, Hughes, Herrera, Fisher, Roenicke, Burton, and Cordero if he is not traded. I think this can make quite a team, a good balance of left and right-handed hitters. What would everyone else do?
Re: If you were GM what would you do in the next 10 days??
I'd give Rick Sweet a hint that there could be a promotion coming at the end of the season.
I'd trade Arroyo or Harang and keep the other for the rest of this season and all of next season.
I'd begin getting Votto one start a week in Left Field.
I'd DFA Willy Taveras and Jerry Hairston, Jr.
In the trade for Harang or Arroyo, I'd try to get a Major League Shortstop.
I'd keep Edwin and try to trade him during the off-season, as his value will be higher and the club's prospects at 3rd Base will be more clear.
Re: If you were GM what would you do in the next 10 days??
Heck, I'd trade Weathers AND Rhodes if you can get any kind of booty for both of them. If not, keep one. Heck, I'd trade Arroyo AND Harang too. I think Aaron's hitting his decline and it would be smart to move him while he still has value. I just don't see either one of those guys being much better than replacement level next year, so why not move them now? Those 4 guys would be the guys I'd look to move, but not to make a move just to make one, only if it helps the team in 2010-11. I don't care about 2009 at this point. Cordero is an interesting chip as well.
I would also look to deal with AL clubs, because that league is so much better than the NL right now anybody with any success at all in the AL would blossom in the NL.
Re: If you were GM what would you do in the next 10 days??
I would trade either Harang or Arroyo, possibly both to unload their contracts, and sign a bat with that free money in the offseason.
I would trade Weathers, and probably keep Rhodes since he's under contract at a steal of a price for next year.
Won't be able to trade Ramon now, but I wouldve done that before the injury.
And then i'd kick myself for not getting a bat in the offseason or even during the season when it still mattered and my team had a chance to do something. I'd have a hard time sleeping at night, knowing I knew what the problem was, and didn't try to fix it before it was too late. Thats what I would do.
Re: If you were GM what would you do in the next 10 days??
Quote:
Originally Posted by
mroby85
And then i'd kick myself for not getting a bat in the offseason or even during the season when it still mattered and my team had a chance to do something. I'd have a hard time sleeping at night, knowing I knew what the problem was, and didn't try to fix it before it was too late. Thats what I would do.
It kind of reminds me of the Cavs trading for Shaq in the offseason, the Cavs could have made the same move midseason last year but didn't, and they got punished for it in the playoffs. Everyone knew the Reds needed a bat(s) to compete, but instead of solving the problem now they are going to fix it when it is already too late.
Re: If you were GM what would you do in the next 10 days??
I would just quite my job.
Re: If you were GM what would you do in the next 10 days??
I'd trade Arroyo for whatever I could get to dump his salary, and would move Harang if I could get a decent price. I'd also look to trade Weathers and maybe Rhoads. I
'd also keep my eye out for a guy that could be the long term answer for the RH bat issue. I told a friend of mine last year that even though the Reds were "sellers" that I would have LOVED for them to make a run at Jason Bay (and I still wish that they had). If you can find a youngish RH bat that isn't a rent-a-player, I'd work to make that happen.
Re: If you were GM what would you do in the next 10 days??
I would drink as much beer as humanly possible and hope some team gets desperate enough to take some of this chaff off my hands.
Re: If you were GM what would you do in the next 10 days??
As always its easier said than done......what SS would you guys be getting for Arroyo/Harang? I seriously doubt Arroyo and Weathers would get you SS-Wood alone.
I would FIRE Dusty
Get someone with half a manager's brain in there and this team is instantly improved.
Trade EE while hes still got some value.
*a little bit more long team plan*
I would try to aquire some great role players like the Ryan Theriots, Mark DeRosas, Jeff Keppingers (funny we traded him) and surround my young players with guys who have the basic fundamentals. With some guys who can flat "get it done" combined with budding young guys like Votto & Bruce and I think your 1 big bat away from a really dangerous team with the type of talent our young starting pitchers have.
Re: If you were GM what would you do in the next 10 days??
Send Micah Owings to Louisville and tell them he is the every day left fielder and see if he hits.
Re: If you were GM what would you do in the next 10 days??
Choice 1--Stand pat with the team I have now, but level with the fans. You know, the old "we've got a good young nucleus but we don't want to mortgage our future" line.
-----OR-----
Choice 2--If choice 1 seems undesirable, DO SOMETHING. Don't tell the fans we're buyers & then sit on my hands while things get worse each week. Heck, after the LA & Chi series, we'll probably have no chance to even finish at .500, much less enter the playoffs. But if I'm not going to stand pat, make some kind of a move.
I'm just so frustrated at the seeming paradox...we're buyers. but we're just not buying right now.