Originally Posted by
reds44
I'm going to assume Cueto and Marshall won't be back.
Locks (for me):
Mesoraco
Hanigan
Votto
Phillips
Cozart
Fraizer
Hannahan
Ludwick
Choo
Bruce
Heisey
Hamilton
Bailey
Latos
Leake
Arroyo
Cingrani
Parra
Hoover
Simon
Broxton
LeCure
Chapman
Which leaves two bubble spots to decide between Paul, Robinson, Izturis, maybe a guy like Donald or Burris in AAA, or another pitcher or two.
A lot of it will decide on how the last two months play out. I think D-Rob deserves to be on the playoff roster, but him and Hamilton seems a bit redundant. If they view Hamilton as stricly a PR and that's it, that gets D-Rob on it.
I'd probably choose D-Rob and Paul as the last two.