Help me with a roster decision
My pitching staff is:
Mark Prior
Jason Schmidt
Javier Vazquez
Randy Wolf
Brett Myers
Ted Lilly
Joel Pineiro
Randy Johnson (DL)
Keith Foulke
Eddie Guardado
I am deciding if I should do something to this staff.
I like Ted Lilly and Pineiro, but they have almost been unbearable as of late. Should I hang onto them? I like Pineiro more than Lilly, although across the board, Pineiro's stats are worse than Lilly's. I was thinking of doing the following
A) Drop Lilly, pick up Sidney Ponson off waivers
B) Drop Pineiro, pick Ponson off waivers
C) Drop Lilly, pick up Jason Isringhausen off waivers
D) Drop Pineiro, pick Isringhausen off waivers
E) Drop Lilly, pick up Percival off waivers
F) Drop Pineiro, pick Percival off waivers.
G) Do nothing and keep Lilly and Pineiro
Also, at 3B I have the "incredibly underachieving" Edgardo Alfonzo. Should I pick up Aramis Ramirez, or Mark Teixeira and drop Alfonzo.
Ramirez has hit .548 with 9 RBI and 0 K in the last week (until today), where he went 1-4 with a double and an RBI against Prior.
Teixeira has hit .318 with 3 HR and 12 RBI over the last week.
Meanwhile, Alfonzo, who I've been holding onto all season hoping he breaks out, hit .231 with 0 RBI
What should I do?
Which would you do?