Songwriter Wins Copyright Case In Spite Of Herself
Throwing a bone to the lawyer types on the board:
Quote:
In the end, it's entirely possible that there was infringement here. Certainly the judge -- despite all of the problems with Harley's actions in the case -- felt the songs were similar enough to grant summary judgment. But if you're looking for a guide in how not to go about a lawsuit, this seems to be it.
http://www.techdirt.com/articles/201...-herself.shtml
:fineprint:
Re: Songwriter Wins Copyright Case In Spite Of Herself
Hilarious. This reads like something out of a good sitcom:
Quote:
JUDGE: I will not entertain questions. Your motion also indicated that the manner of the removal of the reference also indicated some sort of bias. Everything that has been done in this matter has proceeded according to the routine practice for all matters that have come to me.
MS. HARLEY: Objection.
JUDGE: That is it, counsel. We are adjourned on this matter. Thank you.
MS. HARLEY: Objection.
THE CLERK: All rise.
Re: Songwriter Wins Copyright Case In Spite Of Herself
Thanks for the link jojo. I'm going to check out the docket. Curious to see what actual damages she proved. As the article notes, very unusual to opt for actual damages over statutory damages.
Re: Songwriter Wins Copyright Case In Spite Of Herself
Objection! (I received my law degree from Columbia.... turns out the BAR requires one from THIS country)
Re: Songwriter Wins Copyright Case In Spite Of Herself
Intellectual property law (patents and copyrights) in this country is broken.
Re: Songwriter Wins Copyright Case In Spite Of Herself
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Yachtzee
Intellectual property law (patents and copyrights) in this country is broken.
I agree completely.
Re: Songwriter Wins Copyright Case In Spite Of Herself
66 people read this and no one got my reference? I am now sad for Redszone.
Re: Songwriter Wins Copyright Case In Spite Of Herself
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Yachtzee
Intellectual property law (patents and copyrights) in this country is broken.
I practice in this area and I couldn't agree more.
Re: Songwriter Wins Copyright Case In Spite Of Herself
Quote:
Originally Posted by
dougdirt
66 people read this and no one got my reference? I am now sad for Redszone.
I know that Jeff Winger said something similar on Community.
Re: Songwriter Wins Copyright Case In Spite Of Herself
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Razor Shines
I know that Jeff Winger said something similar on Community.
You have restored my faith in Redszone.
Re: Songwriter Wins Copyright Case In Spite Of Herself
Quote:
Originally Posted by
dougdirt
Objection! (I received my law degree from Columbia.... turns out the BAR requires one from THIS country)
Do you mean Colombia?
Re: Songwriter Wins Copyright Case In Spite Of Herself
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Knightro28
Do you mean Colombia?
NO! (yes)