Which starter would you want?

Which of these 4 guys would you want to have for the rest of the season?

Kelvim Escobar
Tim Hudson
Ted Lilly
Jeremy Guthrie

All these guys are on a team I'm looking to make a deal with. They would join Sheets, Shields, Zambrano, Hill, and Gorzelanny in my rotation. I also have Harden but I'm not going to expect anything, just take it as bonus if he does well.

Also, what type of SP would you expect in return if you were trading Francisco Cordero straight up for that SP?

I'd take Hudson.

I would expect a second tier starter and go for someone who would help you in a category you need (i.e., Ks, Ws). Hard to say who you should expect...it all depends on what your needs are and who is on your targeted team's roster.

I think Hudson is your best bet as well. The other three just don't have nearly the track record that Tim can bring to your team.

I agree with the others, Hudson.

Having said that, Harden is supposed to go back into the rotation this weekend.

Kelvim Escobar. I believe he has the better offense, and I would feel pretty safe handing a lead to the back-end of the Angels bullpen.