Final Win Shares
 

http://www.hardballtimes.com/thtstat...&Submit=Submit

Reds Win Shares, final, from The Hardball Times:
Bronson Arroyo 21
Adam Dunn 20
Aaron Harang 17
Rich Aurilia 16
Scott Hatteberg 15
Brandon Phillips and Edwin Encarnacion 14
Dave Ross and Ryan Freel 13
Austin Kearns and Ken Griffey 10
David Weathers and Felipe Lopez 9
Todd Coffey 8
Eric Milton 7
Jason LaRue 5
Kyle Lohse 4
Elizardo Ramirez, Javier Valentin, Matt Belisle, Juan Castro, and Scott Schoenweis all with 3
Seven players with 2, and seven others with 1.

Re: Final Win Shares
 

Interesting, for SP, Santana led the way with 25 WS, Arroyo was tied for 3rd with 21 and Harang tied for 9th with 17.

I'm not sure what the definition of an ace is, but one could make an argument that for 2006, the Reds had two of them, with two pitchers in the top 12 in MLB in win shares.

Re: Final Win Shares
 

I believe a WS is supposed to be worth about 1/3 a win so by that measurement Arroyo was worth 7 wins this year, maybe more considering who would have replaced him.