Evaluate this trade
 

Which team got the better of this deal? It is a 10 team, PPR, dynasty league (keep as many as you want as long as you want).

Team A gets:
Chris Johnson
Marshawn Lynch
Mohammad Massaquoi
Lance Kendricks
4th round pick in next year's rookie/free agent draft

Team B gets:
Ahmad Bradshaw
Brandon Marshall
Beanie Wells
Jermaine Greshem

Re: Evaluate this trade
 

Team B all the way. Chris Johnson is great and all but if you look at it like this ..

Johnson for Bradshaw & Marshall

Lynch, Massaquoi, Kendricks, 4th rnd for Beanie & Gresham

The first trade is fair, I'd take Beanie & Gresham in the 2nd trade every time.

Re: Evaluate this trade
 

Team B is getting a lopsided deal. I see it the same as Buckeye33. Essentially Johnson and junk for a 4 really useful guys.

Re: Evaluate this trade
 

Also, in this league we start 3 RB and 4 WR, if that makes a difference.

Re: Evaluate this trade
 

Still lopsided to team B.

Re: Evaluate this trade
 

With Gore out I need a RB.

I was offered.
FJax and J. Best for
McFadden and B. Marshall.

That's an easy "no", right?

Re: Evaluate this trade
 

Trade advice as well. Keeper league. You start QB, RB, WR, WR, 2 Flex, TE, D. You can have a kicker start as a flex position.

Here is a breakdown of my team
QB: Matt Ryan, Cutler
RB: MJD, Steven Jackson, Daniel Thomas, Roy Helu
WR: Miles Austin, AJ Green, Plax,
TE: Gronk
D: Pack and Lions

The rest of my team is basically fodder. Ernest Graham, Kendell Hunter, A. Benn, etc.

Anyway someone in the league is offering Rivers for RB. I mentioned trading MJD for him and he responded with MJD and Matt Ryan. Now its a 4 keeper league and my keepers right now look like MJD, Steven Jackson, AJ Green, and Miles Austin. Is MJD and Ryan too steep a price to pay for Rivers? Without MJD my starting RB's would be Steven Jackson and Daniel Thomas.

Re: Evaluate this trade
 

What are your keeper rules? How long could you hold Rivers and/or Ryan? MJD is not a long term guy in my book.

Re: Evaluate this trade
 

No, and you get to make fun of the guy in the response line.

Re: Evaluate this trade
 

For as long as possible. I think I am going to turn it down. The trade we discussed was Ryan and MJD for Rivers and Reggie Bush. My problem was that there wasn't too much of a difference between Ryan and Rivers to make me willing to part with MJD.

Re: Evaluate this trade
 

I would keep Ryan and MJD.
Ryan and Cutler should get you a pretty good amount of points even if they don't get what the top QBs get.
MJD is a guy that you can usually count on getting his carries and will usually stay in the game even when his team his down due to his pass catching ability.

Re: Evaluate this trade
 

Yeah no on that one too. Reggie Bush is fantasy poison.

Re: Evaluate this trade
 

Ryan actually was one of my biggest mistakes. You were allowed to keep 4 players and I kept Ryan, MJD, Steven Jackson, and Miles Austin while letting Vincent Jackson go. Ryan was one of the "weaker" keepers but I was high on him.