Originally Posted by reds44
Right now Clayton is better defensively, I am not debating that.
The offense isn't even close though. I hope you don't think Royce is a better player then Edwin.
Dunn is a terrible defender, should we start Denorfia over him?
The two situations are not comparable at all. Left field is a offensive position. SS has become more of a balance of the two, but I still considere SS a defensive position, especially since they are considered the leaders of the infield. I'll take the defense at SS, especially when you aren't really lacking offense from other positions.