I'm just noting that a Rowandish future would be a disappointment
Matter of opinion. It was a weak draft, and getting a league-average CF with excellent defense is OK by me. Lots of top ten guys fail completely -- though it should be noted that at the top of the draft college hitters have higher success rates, so, for me, anything less than Rowandesque will mean they didn't evaluate or develop Stubbs properly.
Of course, if the criterion for a disappointment is that the player didn't end up outperforming every draftee taken after him -- as sometimes appears to be the case -- then he, like most draftees of all time, will be a disappointment.