Re: Reds All-Time Outfield
Robinson and Rose are no brainers. There careers were long and productive, with their best years with the Reds.
The third pick is harder.
Roush is probably easily deserving, but I never saw him play, so it's easier for me to ignore him. Not logical, I would admit.
So for me, it came down to Foster, Davis and Pinson.
Foster had the best peak years, but his career was relativly short. The same can be said for Davis. Both were wondweful ballpalyers.
I went with Pinson, because he was a great player, over many years, but was easily overlooked. He needed my vote more. He also brought us Granger and Tolan in a trade so he was productive even after he left.