Originally Posted by Highlifeman21
Salty is playing at the MLB level.
Can you say the same for any of the 4 I listed?
That would be no, no, no, and no.
Votto's the only one that seems to be a "sure" thing to get some MLB experience anytime soon. The other 3 are still crap shoots.
I think it would be organizationally responsibly (ok, I might have made up that phrase...) to use minor league assets to attain major league talent.
We don't have any C prospects anywhere on the radar. Getting Salty solves that problem.
No, I cant say that about any of them. But if I could choose trading 4 months worth of Adam Dunn for 6 years of Salty vs trading 4 of our top 10 prospects for 6 years of Salty, I would trade Dunn without thinking twice. Given his contract status, its not really a difficult decision for me.