Originally Posted by dougdirt
No, I cant say that about any of them. But if I could choose trading 4 months worth of Adam Dunn for 6 years of Salty vs trading 4 of our top 10 prospects for 6 years of Salty, I would trade Dunn without thinking twice. Given his contract status, its not really a difficult decision for me.
I would pick 6 years of Salty for the 4 "prospects" vs. 6 years of Salty for 4 months of Adam Dunn.
Keep Adam Dunn, obtain Salty while not sacrificing MLB talent. I don't see why this is a hard concept.
We know what we have in Adam Dunn, we know what he'll give us.
We have zero clue what Votto, Stubbs, Cueto and Wood can offer.
We have a pretty good idea what Salty can offer.
Adam Dunn > Votto, Stubbs, Cueto and Wood IMO.