Originally Posted by BuckeyeRedleg
As the new guys sign, this list will be altered.
Example, if Mesoraco and Frazier were signed today, they would be #4 and #5 (ahead of Stubbs and Francisco), right out of the gate.
I agree, although I think you may be selling Francisco short a little bit. If he's OPSing 100 pts higher than Stubbs at the same level and he's four years younger, I think its tough to rank him behind him solely because Stubbs was a former 1st round pick.
If D-Mes and Frazier signed today, I would rank them like this:
Mesoraco needs to make it to A-ball before he can crack the top 5 IMO. Otherwise you could put Justin Reed up there as well. Stubbs is beginning to get dangerously close to pre-June BJ Syzmanski territory (who ironically, is finally starting to hit).
Edit: Nevermind, I see you now have Francisco ahead of Stubbs.