Originally Posted by Benihana
I don't neccessarily think you're wrong, but Hamilton could most certainly get there also. And while I know a bird in the hand... is it really worth giving up a very effective and cheap starting SS as well as the organization's #1 pitching prospect just to get something you may already have?
Not to mention cheaper, younger, and signed for longer...
Yep, totally worth it as far as I'm concerned. Do it in a heartbeat. Sure stud RF and an advanced catching prospect for a maybe stud RF, an aging SS and a 21-year-old pitcher? You'd have to pinch me.
Though I didn't start the thread to talk about my off-the-wall proposal, I started it to see how creative people could get on trade proposals.