Originally Posted by Buckeye33
Here is how I would look at it.
Reyes, Utley, Holliday > Wright, Berkman, Crawford
Gonzalez, Wood, Haren, Zumaya < Liriano, Lackey, Figgins, Saito
So you got the better end of the elite players, he got a little better in the good players. Liriano is the key on his side. If he comes back and is what he was last year then it's pretty even deal.
Good healthy trade for both teams and I'm sure took a lot of time.
that's kinda how i made the decision, definitely agree Liriano is Key to the whole thing for him, i decided:
Reyes > Wright
Utley > Figgins
Holliday > Crawford, not by much though
Gonzalez = Berkman
Wood and Haren < Lackey and Liriano
Zumaya < Saito, for now, not future though.