Originally Posted by tripleaaaron
Huh? Just because he wasn't worthy of a spot on a team that consistently is in the playoff race means that he is not a 3 because he now plays for a team that isn't in the playoff race but thought enough of him to keep him on the 25 man in order to retain his rights? That doesn't make any sense, the kid has talent and should be a 3* for sure. But like you say he should probably actually be removed from this list as he isn't a prospect anymore. But for the sake of argument, you would rather have every guy on this list over Burton? Thats crazy.
Please forgive me, Mr. Burton.
Again, I was giving my honest opinion on one of my more difficult decisions. Obviously none of those other 3*'s on the list are ready to do what Burton is doing right now, but I guarantee that someday some will and with a higher ceiling.
Like I said, this thing will be changing. I spent enough time just putting the thing together that the ratings were not something that felt I had time to go crazy over. The point is that it's a starting point. I follow college football recruiting pretty closely and early on, the databases assign most recruits 1 or 2 stars just to get them in the system and then go from there.
Like I said, I'm sure there are some inconsistencies and appreciate any feedback, as long as it's somewhat friendly.