Originally Posted by RedsFan75
That's the real thing there, without an O-Line doesn't matter how much talent a QB has it's tough for him to excel when he's fighting for his life.
2 shoulder surgeries make it tough for a QB to come back to form.
I think it depends on the quarterback personally. Vince Young and Michael Vick may have more success with a shabby offensive line, while Peyton Manning would have a career similar to Tim Couch if he had the Browns O-Line while Couch was there.
Couch really was doomed from the get-go. He was going to an expansion franchise as a rookie, which generally does not work well. Not to mention he didn't have that great of a field awareness compared to a Peyton Manning or Tom Brady.