Re: Ichiro vs. Dunn
They are completely different styles of hitters. It's not fair to either player to compare them (nor is it to compare Ty Cobb and Ichiro to an empty ba like Alex Sanchez), without one you dont get the other (as we have seen).
Give me my choice of any 7 power hitters and then for the 8th Dunn or Ichiro I would take Ichiro.
Likewise if I had Pete Rose, Rickey Henderson, Ty Cobb types, plus a couple good/not great power hitters I take Dunn for the RBI potential.