Originally Posted by RedsMightWin
What would you rather have 9 dunns in your line up or 9 ichiros. Honestly i would take the ichiros.
Why do you keep bringing up this idea of having 9 of one player in a lineup? It's a moot point because you never want a lineup full of one type of player.
Besides, this comparison makes little sense because Ichiro and Dunn are totally different type of hitters. I'd want them both in my lineup.