Originally Posted by gedred69
Looking at the list 1-25, it will be interesting to see in 2 years, how many of these guys have made it or at least shown they WILL make it. IMO after the 1st 5, the list is a questionable as to where certain players belong #-wise. (A lot of voting from the heart). Outside of Dayton and Louisville, I wonder how many responders have actually seen players at Billings, Sarasota, Chattanooga play enough to be able to evaluate intangibles that might not show up on a stat sheet.
I have yet to vote for anyone who hasn't had success at AA. It is a long way from Billings to Cincinnati. Guys like Dickerson or Pelland may be role players at best in the bigs but they will get a shot and some of the guys already on our list will never see the bigs.