Re: Hanigan ROY?
Per John Fay: "He hit .271 in 31 games with the Reds last season, but because he didn't have 130 AB (he had 126) or appear on the active roster for 45 days, he retained his rookie status."
He's definitely a rookie, as a couple of you have stated. He has thrown out 10 of 22 runners trying to steal, which LEADS THE MAJORS among catchers with 20 or more chances. He is batting .325 with a .411 OBP. He is without a doubt deserving of playing time once Votto comes back and of the ROY.