Originally Posted by Mario-Rijo
I'd still trade Alonso and keep Votto. Alonso for Asdrubal Cabrera sounds like a deal I could get behind. If they could expand that deal to include Shin Soo Choo for LF as well they would fill 2 (maybe even 3) expansive holes cheaply and make this team a legit contender. The tribe is re-building anyway and need top end talent at the corner IF positions which we have some of.
I don't know exactly what would work but how about...
Reds get Cabrera, Choo & Jamey Carroll
Tribe gets Alonso, Wood, Francisco, Watson and Cozart
Really improves our 25 man and cleans up some spots for the 40 man in the mean time.
So you would rather trade Alonso, Wood, Francisco, Cozart and something else than Joey Votto by himself?