Re: Indianapolis folks
Rathskeller is fun as I've been there multiple times. Not sure if we want to go walk all the way down there. IIRC, it's a long walk from the St. Elmo's/Ruth's Chris locations. I've also heard that Mass Ave is starting to become a nice play. I went to the Chatham Tap when it first opened. It's more of a soccer bar, but I liked it. It's just different.
Other than that, something simple to do. I'm leaning toward St. Elmo's. I'm not rich by any stretch of the imagination, but this is more of a once a year type of event to treat my girl.