Re: The Best Fantasy Pitching Staff EVAR!
Originally Posted by nmculbreth
Lets compare the two rotations side by side:
Roy Halladay vs. Roy Halladay - Push.
Tim Lincecum vs. Justin Verlander - Lincecum by a wide margin.
Zack Greinke vs. Johan Santana - Greinke.
Dan Haren vs. Max Scherzer - Haren by a wide margin.
Chris Carpenter vs. Phil Hughes - Carpenter by an even wider margin.
Mariano Rivera vs. Mariano Rivera - Push.
Andrew Bailey vs. Heath Bell - Push. Bailey has some injury risk, Bell may end up getting traded.
Ryan Franklin vs. Francisco Cordero - Cordero.
David Aardsma vs. Jon Rauch - Aardsma.
Despite the added "depth" provided by Harang and Cueto, I'm not sure how this is even a debate...
Personally I would give the nod to Bell over Bailey.
Somebody's gotta win and somebody's gotta lose and I believe in letting the other guy lose.