Re: Thanks... But No Thanks
It's an interesting concept. Personally I liked the parts of the Rep system we had here at one time. Lots of people say interesting or thought provoking posts here, and I like telling them that without having to type up a PM everytime it happens. A Quick hit of a button telling them so was nice, clean and easy. I could do without the negative parts and without the broadcasting of your rep points, that always leads to abuse and issues.
If you could figure out a way to make it less public - IE not show up in the threads but just to let the users know I think this could be a push in the right direction.
Also FYI - The Reds Away theme which I always use doesn't have a graphic button setup for the Thanks yet.