Originally Posted by kaldaniels
Just a thought, but I'd like to see a "poll" done where the top 10-20 prospects are rated "MVP-style", with a 10-9-8-7-etc....points system rather than voting on prospect 1, then moving on to 2, etc....that may give us a better across-the-board look at how Redszone views their prospects. For instance, if I think Grandal is actually the 10th best prospect, this system eliminates that opinion from its rankings, as Grandal is out of the discussion by the time #10 rolls around. Not to say I don't enjoy these threads...I love them!
I agree. That is a much better system. And I also agree that I love the idea of a Message Board top prospects list to compare to the "national experts". However, is the list a true reflection of the different opinions on the board? With the current list, people vote prospect place by place, rather than the place of the prospect by prospect. Its more "fun" and "social" to do the poll this way - you can vote for who you think will win (again - place by place) but its not logical. Then again, I recognize that I take prospect analysis and ranking pretty seriously, perhaps too seriously. So I may be in the minority here.