Originally Posted by dougdirt
In theory, the other way would work better..... if everyone voting actually had a lot of information on the players they were voting on. But, I don't really think most do beyond a handful of guys and this way actually allows us to discuss everyone and get more information out there on the guys.
If I am understanding you correctly, this is a system/prospect promotional thread for the board. I never thought of it that way before.
You are aware though, that national prospect-related experts may not be as knowledgeable on all aspects of the Reds system as some local prospect oriented fans, right? So if the prospect rankings reflected more of the specific knowledge of the board, rather than the general zeal of the board, they could concievably influence national rankings, instead of mirror them.