Originally Posted by kaldaniels
Grossly unfair to say I don't like Manning Razor. He is top 5 of all time and is a class act.
I throw around the term "choke job" for guys that I really like too
. Especially when it's not accurate. Watch the replay. Wayne runs one route, Manning throws to another.
YouTube - Tracy Porter Game Winning Interception vs. Colts in Super Bowl 44
Like I say, the argument could be made that maybe they should rethink their offense to ensure they're on the same page, but it wasn't a bad throw. Manning threw it right to Porter, it wasn't like he was trying to fit it into tight coverage. He didn't throw it anywhere near Wayne, so either you'd have to believe that Manning is just awful or Wayne ran a different route than what Manning believed him to be running.
Maybe you do like him, but I just don't see how anyone could honestly think that was a bad throw. It wasn't an overthrow or an underthrow, it wasn't a mistake in trying to fit a pass in somewhere that he couldn't.