Originally Posted by mth123
1. Not sure at 1B .300/.400/.500 is an all star.
2. Alonso has never had an OPS of .900 in any season so far.
He put up an .880 one year at A+ and its the best he's done. At AAA he's at .825 in 445 PAs, yet he's ranked ahead of those .900+ guys like Trumbo, Allen, Duda, Francisco etc. that I posted above. He's viewed as the #73 prospect in baseball with an OPS below that of Danny Dorn who has more success and more versatility and can't get a roster spot. I don't see how he's being sold short.
In his one year at A+, it was the FSL. If he were in the CAL that probably would have been a 1.000 OPS. As for his AAA numbers, I am not worried about them when a good chunk of them came with him recovering from the hamate issue. Dude is going to rake and has when healthy, with all of the right peripherals.