Originally Posted by Johnny Footstool
He plays Gold Glove defense in that he's very flashy and can make incredible plays. However, his dWAR is usually right around 0.
And he has said he won't give the Reds any kind of discount.
Clearly you are not using Fangraphs' WAR. Only Chase Utley has been better at 2B over the past five years at 2B than BP has using Fangraphs UZR, which is used to compute WAR.