Originally Posted by mth123
But these guys are probably improvements over the guys the Reds had slated for the AAA rotation. Now the rotation is probably Chapman, Reinecke, Gallagher, Atilano and Tanner. Way better than Klinker, Hynick, McCulloch and probably Carroll. Carroll might be OK if Chapman stays on the big club in the pen, but the AAA rotation is pretty weak IMO. These guys are upgrades.
Who do Gallagher and Atilano replace?
I don't see those two as way better than anyone you listed (Klinker, Hynick, McCulloch, Carroll). Are they better just because they have MLB experience (even though they were both awful)?