Originally Posted by Scrap Irony
I really don't want to get into this again, but if I were to show you tweets and quotes from respected baseball talent evaluators that commented on his extreme athelticism, would you then admit you were wrong?
No. You continue to not understand what I am saying. Billy Hamilton is arguably the most athletic player the Reds have the rights to, Majors or Minors. I still don't consider him a super athlete on par with a guy like Josh Hamilton who can run very fast, throw very hard, jump very high and has big time strength. Those are the things I consider when I think of a super athlete, which is what was originally brought up.