Originally Posted by RedsMan3203
Could this happen........
Todd Frazier.... ROY
Johnny Cueto.... Cy Young
Joey Votto..... MVP
Has this ever happened in the past???
I think all 3 have a great shot at each award.....
Whoa. I can't imagine there's any way that happens--the weirdest thing about baseball awards is voters tend to look at a whole lot of other factors than player-isolated statistics (history, team performance, etc.). Particularly with Joey missing a month. But look at this:
OPS: Votto 1.069, first place
Rookie OPS (min. 200 PAs): Frazier .872, first place
ERA+: Johnny Cueto 187, first place
That may be cherry picking a little bit. How about WAR?
WAR: Votto 4.8, fifth place
Rookie WAR: Frazier 1.8, first place
Pitching WAR: Cueto 3.5, third place