Originally Posted by dougdirt
Henderson's stats aren't really like Hamilton's in the minors either. So I would have to find you one, not another one.
I don't really care to do it though. Hamilton is a unique player with a unique skillset. I don't believe that his minor league numbers are going to translate 1 to 1, particularly in the walk area. So even if I did find someone with stats that are similar, it wouldn't particularly do much good for a comparison for me.
I need to remind you this thread is about voting for minor league player of the year. Your belief in Hamilton's numbers translating to the majors don't matter (of course you assume Taveras's numbers will, but let's just ignore that).
I have been trying to show over and over again why Hamilton's numbers are either similar or in fact superior to Taveras's numbers in the minors. That is all. You started by stating how incredible the other guy's seasons are, and I have shown through countless number of stats how incredible Hamilton's season is in comparison. He is not just a bunch of steals like you wanted to think.