Originally Posted by mth123
Tough call. McCutchen was the choice until he faded. I like Chapman, but Kimbrel is just as dominant. I don't think Braun gets a repeat after last off-season. Votto's injury knocks him out. Same with Stanton. I think Wright is not considered because of his team's record. Kemp missed half the year. Melky had a shot until the testing.
Posey or Holliday might be the guys. McCutchen still has a shot as well.
I agree Braun won't get it because of the PEDs brouhaha and people won't be inclined to vote for him this year for that reason, but he deserves to win it nonetheless. Of course there is still a month left in the season and things will likely look different on October 1st.