Originally Posted by Benihana
Not for me it wouldn't. Way too much risk for a potential "reward" of $5MM per year, discounted back (present value) 6-10 years.
If we don't sign him for an extra 5 years today, he might cost $20M per season for another 10 years at age 30.
It's likley never bad getting premium players signed only to the age 35. Those last 5 years is what generally kills the value of FA.