Originally Posted by Red Buckeye
Fair enough. You guys win! But even if the playoffs have no bearing on COY I think it'd be hard to argue Johnson shouldn't have won it. How many games under .500 did Washington finish in 2011? I don't know and am just asking but to go from yearly losers to the best MLB record is quite a feat.
Bounty, sorry to come off condenscending in my original response. Looking back at my post I owe you an apology.
I do think that Johnson deserved to win it. I just didn't agree with arguement that what happened in the playoffs count toward MOY. Whether it should or shouldn't is a whole nother arguement....