Originally Posted by joe51391
Then take out Collins and Lotzkar and add Corcino does that make it more realistic
Just some words of advice when trying to make up realistic fake trade proposals...
Teams rarely, if ever, trade productive players who have yet to reach arbitration unless there is a stud player coming back to them. These players are extremely valuable. In the case of Moustakas or Perez, you would pay $10M or more each on the open market and Collins would demand $4-5M for their production and they get them for 500k each.
Teams rarely, if ever, trade the minor league player of the year without a stud player coming back to them.
Your proposal above has 4 of the aforementioned productive pre-arbitration players and/or top prospects. That's the kind of package a team may put together for Joey Votto. Not for a package of B level prospects, a middle of the rotation starter and a good catching prospect.