Originally Posted by Scrap Irony
This now reminds me a bit of the Billy Hamilton isn't really an athlete thread.
Which you still don't seem to grasp. I never said he wasn't an athlete. in fact, on multiple occasions I have said he is the best athlete we have in the Reds system. What I said, is that he isn't what I would consider a "super athlete" because he lacks any kind of physical strength. Josh Hamilton. Mike Trout. Ken Griffey Jr. Guys like that are super athletes to me. Guys who can hit the ball a mile. Run past you. Run over you. Throw it by you. Those guys are super athletes. Billy Hamilton isn't in that group. Billy Hamilton is a fine athlete. He just isn't in that class.