Originally Posted by dougdirt
I don't care how young or old Dalton is, he doesn't have it in him to be a winner. He isn't the guy to carry you. He is a guy who can not hurt you. He doesn't have the arm to be the man to carry a team. He is a solid quarterback. He won't be any more than that.
So being 2 for 2 as QB for a playoff team doesn't qualify him as a winner? I've seen comparisons to Kitna, and I get that, but I see more of a Ken Anderson career. He took the team to a Super Bowl and was a goal line stand away from being a Super Bowl winning QB.
The loser was also putting up some pretty impressive stats during the run midseason until Sanu gets hurt. He is above average in his first two years, started as a rookie, and has been to the playoff both years of his career. He led his college team to a Rose Bowl victory as the MVP, came from famed the Katy HS program...........I'd say his pedigree and resume is pretty strong against such a bold low ceiling prediction.