Originally Posted by Hoosier Red
Well you specifically said there weren't 16 quarterbacks you'd take ahead of him. Which of those 16 would you argue he's been better than so far?
Can he get better? Sure. So can pretty much everyone on that list. Who would you see him providing more value than over the next 3 years?
I'm not sure we disagree as a whole. My disagreement was mainly with another poster who said his first two years were "Crazy good."
But on the whole, I don't think even a Matt Schaub helps a team get to the Super Bowl. He may not detract from their chances, but if everything else on the team has to be elite because the quarterback is just above average, it strikes me as a flawed plan.
I wouldn't trade him for Josh Freeman for sure. RG3's career is in limbo. I'm not sold on QBs who are 5'10", and I don't want he 2012 version of Phillip Rivers.
Dalton is adequate for now and I'm open to looking for an upgrade if it presents itself but we have a lot bigger holes to fill than QB