Originally Posted by edabbs44
If your entire argument is based around ERA+, maybe the statement should be about the Hall of Top 10 in ERA+. Not trying to be disrespectful, but I think there could be more than ERA+.
Of course there could be, but earned runs is essentially what pitchers are judged upon, no? The guy threw a bunch of innings. But he was never really among the elite in his entire career at keeping runs off of the board. Something elite pitchers do.