Originally Posted by edabbs44
Blyleven > Nolan Ryan
Fister = Cain and Hamels
Chuck Finley > Bob Feller
Jose Rijo > Warren Spahn
Felix + Greinke (14 total seasons) = Kevin Appier
Well, you've actually got two of the most overrated pitchers in history in there. You've also got some wrong information.
Appier and Finley (who did not have a higher career ERA+ than Feller) were better than people remember. Rijo lost his decline years (and probably some of his peak) to injury, which kept his ERA+ high.
Not really sure why you're adding King Felix and Greinke together. One guy has nothing to do with the other and Felix has been a lot better. And Fister is not even, or all that close, to Cain ad Hamels (who are not even with each other).