Originally Posted by M2
Well, you've actually got two of the most overrated pitchers in history in there. You've also got some wrong information.
Appier and Finley (who did not have a higher career ERA+ than Feller) were better than people remember. Rijo lost his decline years (and probably some of his peak) to injury, which kept his ERA+ high.
Not really sure why you're adding King Felix and Greinke together. One guy has nothing to do with the other and Felix has been a lot better. And Fister is not even, or all that close, to Cain ad Hamels (who are not even with each other).
Sorry if I wasn't completely clear. That list was appearances in the top 10 for a given season.